🔗 Share this article

According to developer statements from the studio behind the title, Arc Raiders seems to employ AI tools for creating select voice lines. This development closely resembles the debate that emerged around the studio's 2023 hit, The Finals.

Title Introduction

Debuted on the last day of October for Sony's console, Windows PC, and Microsoft's console, Arc Raiders is marketed as a easier on-ramp to the loot-and-extract category. Unlike more hardcore titles like Escape from Tarkov, it aims to offer a more approachable experience. The title has largely been strong ratings, maintaining a highly favorable rating on Steam based on over 8,000 gamer feedback.

Development Approach

Within the product's Steam page, a clear disclosure regarding artificially created material invites parallels: In the production phase, we could utilize automated and generative tools to facilitate asset production. Regardless of method, the resulting game embodies the creativity and vision of our studio staff."

Previous Controversy

The Finals, a successful online combat game recognized for its responsive controls and demolition-heavy maps, received negative feedback for its use of AI ahead of its full release. During its public testing phase, the project's audio lead revealed in a online discussion that the development team had leveraged generative technology for creating voice content. This statement triggered swift criticism from industry talent and industry professionals, who stated that AI-generated voices were of notably lower quality compared to human performances and that such practices could replace voice-acting jobs.

Studio Explanation

Reacting to feedback, Embark Studios stated that they had employed skilled voice actors to record original voice lines for The Finals, but expanded these with TTS technology to generate additional content inspired by those initial performances. The company's explanation focused on the significant time savings obtained via this technique.

Latest Developments

Regarding Arc Raiders, the project's design head clarified that the release "in no way uses artificial intelligence creation whatsoever," though he did not provide details on the exact nature of the platform statement. He did acknowledge, however, that the same vocal technology used for The Finals was also applied in Arc Raiders.

We employ a blend of live performance content and material produced using synthetic voice systems in our games, based on the context," commented a development team member. "Sometimes, capturing live performances where actors get together — allowing actor relationships and conflict to influence the result — is something that adds depth to our virtual environments that systems cannot duplicate. Other times, especially when it relates to dynamic gameplay announcements, TTS allows us to have personalized speech where we could not e.g. due to production timelines."

Community Response

Initial response to the incorporation of AI technology in Arc Raiders has been somewhat nuanced, particularly in the early days. A portion of the community have voiced significant concerns.

• Artificial intelligence dialogue is a blemish on an otherwise incredible game," stated one user in a online discussion.
• I oppose that they did it for The Finals and am sad to hear they repeated it for this title," added another.
• The effect was quickly detectable in the speech content for one protagonist," observed a another gamer.

That said, different gamers have taken a more tolerant position.

• I don't care, they paid voice actors and used it well," commented one forum user.
• "This is as ethical as it gets these days, sadly," concluded another.

The persistent controversy surrounding artificial intelligence use in game development seems likely to continue as developers balance creative efficiency with performance standards and ethical considerations.